{
  "id": "vs:surface/narrative-sampling-tableau-public-example",
  "type": "NarrativeSamplingSurfaceState",
  "version": "0.1",
  "surface": {
    "id": "na:narrative-sampling-tableau/public-example-v0.1",
    "canonicalType": "NarrativeSamplingSurface",
    "displayName": "Narrative Sampling Tableau",
    "samplingSystemRef": "na:verbalized-sampling/demo-system",
    "samplingSnapshotRef": "na:verbalized-sampling/demo-snapshot-v0.1",
    "publicationStatus": "public_safe_example",
    "reviewState": "public_reviewed"
  },
  "outcomeDefinition": {
    "id": "vs:outcome/name-hold-conation-motion",
    "statement": "Probability that the selected naming arrangement remains semantically adequate, human-legible, AI-legible, and resistant to material drift across Driftframe documentation and machine-readable contexts for the next 18 months.",
    "subjectRef": "na:concept/conation-motion",
    "eventType": "name_hold",
    "population": "Teams using Driftframe Narrative Architecture with AI systems and related schemas",
    "horizon": "18 months / first implementation and cross-model review cycle",
    "conditions": [
      "Canonical, technical, display, and authored labels may remain separate.",
      "Stable identity and aliases remain versioned.",
      "Product-market framing remains outside the target register."
    ],
    "successCriteria": [
      "The term remains recoverable across at least three model contexts.",
      "Reader-facing material can explain the term without replacing its stable identity.",
      "No material collision forces immediate renaming."
    ],
    "exclusions": [
      "Measured market adoption",
      "Formal legal or trademark clearance",
      "Empirical calibration against future outcomes"
    ],
    "decisionContextRef": "vs:decision/conation-motion-name",
    "sourceRefs": [
      "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1",
      "na:verbalized-sampling"
    ],
    "reviewState": "working"
  },
  "conditionProfile": {
    "id": "vs:conditions/conation-motion-name",
    "outcomeDefinitionRef": "vs:outcome/name-hold-conation-motion",
    "focalizationRef": "na:focalization/conation-motion-naming",
    "population": "Teams using Driftframe Narrative Architecture with AI systems and related schemas",
    "horizon": "18 months",
    "constraints": [
      "The canonical name can differ from the reader-facing display label.",
      "Source provenance remains visible.",
      "A public name should remain emotionally accessible and technically serious."
    ],
    "exclusions": [
      "Brand positioning",
      "Market differentiation"
    ],
    "candidateSetSemantics": "open_exclusive",
    "candidateCountRequested": 5,
    "diversityInstruction": "Return materially distinct naming architectures, including at least one rare disciplinary anchor, one accessible technical phrase, one domain adapter, and one plain-language display option.",
    "tailInstruction": "Reserve explicit mass for unlisted or newly blended alternatives.",
    "modelRef": "vs:model/ai-supported-planning-pass",
    "modelVersion": "mixed-session-evidence",
    "providerOrRuntime": "Human-led planning with an AI system",
    "samplingParameters": {
      "temperature": "not recorded",
      "ordering": "source exemplar order"
    },
    "evidenceRefs": [
      "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
    ],
    "asOf": "2026-06-21",
    "reviewState": "working"
  },
  "promptCapsule": {
    "id": "vs:prompt-capsule/conation-motion-name",
    "displayName": "Conation motion naming fan-out",
    "currentDecision": "Select a stable naming architecture for the concept currently called Conation Motions.",
    "outcomeDefinitionRef": "vs:outcome/name-hold-conation-motion",
    "samplingConditionProfileRef": "vs:conditions/conation-motion-name",
    "samplingGoal": "Explore before converging, then compare baseline and layered-label conditions.",
    "dimensionRefs": [
      "vs:dimension/semantic-stability",
      "vs:dimension/human-legibility",
      "vs:dimension/ai-legibility",
      "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability",
      "vs:dimension/source-fidelity",
      "vs:dimension/future-refactorability",
      "vs:dimension/accessibility"
    ],
    "estimateKindRequested": "planning_judgment",
    "comparisonRunRefs": [
      "vs:run/baseline-single-label",
      "vs:run/layered-label"
    ],
    "shiftQuestion": "How does allowing a rare stable canonical term plus an accessible public display label change the estimated probability that each naming arrangement holds?",
    "diversityInstruction": "Include counter-typical and source-faithful options. Preserve an explicit open tail.",
    "tailInstruction": "Name missing candidate classes and reserve other/tail mass.",
    "confidenceRequested": true,
    "gapReviewRequested": true,
    "outputContract": [
      "candidate identity and rationale",
      "probability estimate with estimate kind and calibration state",
      "dimension scores and weights",
      "tradeoffs, assumptions, failure modes, and evidence needed",
      "methodological gaps and Core Architecture routes",
      "comparison against the baseline run"
    ],
    "sourceBand": [
      "author_created",
      "collaboration_stabilized"
    ],
    "reviewState": "working"
  },
  "dimensions": [
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/semantic-stability",
      "displayName": "Semantic stability",
      "definition": "Likelihood that the term's intended technical meaning remains recognizable across time, models, and contexts.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.25,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "human_steward_review",
        "cross_model_observation"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/human-legibility",
      "displayName": "Human legibility",
      "definition": "Ease with which a skilled but non-specialist collaborator can understand the term at first encounter.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.18,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "human_steward_review",
        "participant_observation"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/ai-legibility",
      "displayName": "AI legibility",
      "definition": "Likelihood that an AI system retrieves a useful semantic neighborhood with limited repair.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.17,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "cross_model_observation",
        "prompt_experiment"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability",
      "displayName": "Cross-model portability",
      "definition": "Consistency of interpretation across model families, versions, and sessions.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.15,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "cross_model_observation"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/source-fidelity",
      "displayName": "Source fidelity",
      "definition": "Preservation of the concept's authored and disciplinary meaning.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.1,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "source_note_only",
        "human_steward_review"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/future-refactorability",
      "displayName": "Future refactorability",
      "definition": "Ability to add display labels, aliases, adapters, or successor terms without breaking stable identity.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.08,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "schema_validation",
        "human_steward_review"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:dimension/accessibility",
      "displayName": "Accessibility",
      "definition": "Ease of pronunciation, scanning, explanation, and use in accessible reader-facing material.",
      "direction": "higher_is_better",
      "weight": 0.07,
      "weightOrigin": "human_declared",
      "sourceOfTruthBand": [
        "participant_observation",
        "accessibility_review"
      ],
      "reviewState": "working"
    }
  ],
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "vs:run/baseline-single-label",
      "displayName": "Baseline · one public term",
      "runPurpose": "Estimate naming hold when one term must serve canonical, technical, and reader-facing roles.",
      "parentRunRef": null,
      "variantRef": null,
      "changedFields": [],
      "runState": "completed",
      "candidateSetSemantics": "open_exclusive",
      "otherOrTailMass": 0.12,
      "missingModeClasses": [
        "layered canonical + display-label architecture",
        "compound technical adapter"
      ],
      "candidates": [
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/conation-motions",
          "displayName": "Conation motions",
          "description": "Rare, source-faithful canonical term with strong semantic stability and low immediate legibility.",
          "candidateKind": "canonical_term",
          "semanticCluster": "rare-disciplinary",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "A public display label may differ from the canonical term.",
            "The term receives a glossary and retrieval aliases."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "High stability and source fidelity.",
            "Requires orientation for many readers."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Reader abandonment when no accessible display layer is present.",
            "AI over-association with historical psychology without local context."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Cross-model interpretation checks and small reader-legibility review.",
          "estimate": 0.28,
          "lowerBound": 0.2,
          "upperBound": 0.38,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 8.9,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 4.2,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 6.8,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 8.8,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 9.5,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 8.0,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 5.5
          },
          "decisionState": "held",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/conative-behavior",
          "displayName": "Conative behavior",
          "description": "A more contemporary disciplinary term balancing technical specificity and initial readability.",
          "candidateKind": "canonical_term",
          "semanticCluster": "disciplinary-balanced",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "Behavior language remains acceptable for the intended collaboration register."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "Good stability.",
            "May sound observational rather than motion-oriented."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Conceptual flattening from motion into behavior category."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Terminological collision review and source-fidelity comparison.",
          "estimate": 0.2,
          "lowerBound": 0.12,
          "upperBound": 0.3,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 8.5,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 6.4,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 7.8,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 8.4,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 8.8,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 7.8,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 6.8
          },
          "decisionState": "selected",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/volitional-actions",
          "displayName": "Volitional actions",
          "description": "Highly legible technical phrase with moderate drift exposure in popular and AI discourse.",
          "candidateKind": "public_or_technical_term",
          "semanticCluster": "legible-academic",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "Volition carries the intended motivational and directional sense."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "High immediate legibility.",
            "Lower long-term semantic stability."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Normative or agency-heavy interpretation.",
            "Semantic softening through popular use."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Cross-model drift review and register assessment.",
          "estimate": 0.18,
          "lowerBound": 0.1,
          "upperBound": 0.28,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 7.6,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 8.9,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 9.0,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 7.5,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 7.2,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 7.2,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.6
          },
          "decisionState": "held",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/motor-intentions",
          "displayName": "Motor intentions",
          "description": "Neuroscience-adjacent technical term with high legibility in movement contexts and narrower conceptual scope.",
          "candidateKind": "domain_adapter",
          "semanticCluster": "neuroscience",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "The concept is close enough to embodied movement to justify motor-language emphasis."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "Strong technical anchor.",
            "May exclude non-motor conative state."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Over-narrowing toward physical movement."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Scope comparison against non-motor examples.",
          "estimate": 0.12,
          "lowerBound": 0.04,
          "upperBound": 0.22,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 8.0,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 8.8,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 8.2,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 7.9,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 5.5,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 6.5,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.2
          },
          "decisionState": "declined",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/motivated-movements",
          "displayName": "Motivated movements",
          "description": "Plainly readable phrase with broad movement semantics and moderate commercial or wellness drift.",
          "candidateKind": "display_term",
          "semanticCluster": "plain-language",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "A broad display label is valuable even when the canonical type remains more technical."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "Strong readability.",
            "Meaning may broaden beyond the intended construct."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Fitness or self-help interpretation.",
            "Loss of volitional nuance."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Reader comprehension review and public-register collision search.",
          "estimate": 0.1,
          "lowerBound": 0.02,
          "upperBound": 0.2,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 7.2,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 9.0,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 8.6,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 7.0,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 6.2,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 6.8,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.4
          },
          "decisionState": "held",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        }
      ],
      "startedAt": "2026-06-20T16:00:00Z",
      "completedAt": "2026-06-20T16:10:00Z",
      "valueOrigin": "human_led_ai_supported",
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:run/layered-label",
      "displayName": "Variant · layered canonical / display labels",
      "runPurpose": "Estimate naming hold when canonical, technical, display, and authored labels can remain separate.",
      "parentRunRef": "vs:run/baseline-single-label",
      "variantRef": "vs:variant/layered-label",
      "changedFields": [
        "constraints.canonical_display_separation",
        "dimensions.human_legibility",
        "dimensions.future_refactorability"
      ],
      "runState": "completed",
      "candidateSetSemantics": "open_exclusive",
      "otherOrTailMass": 0.12,
      "missingModeClasses": [
        "new neutral umbrella term",
        "two-part scientific + plain-language pair"
      ],
      "candidates": [
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/conation-motions",
          "displayName": "Conation motions",
          "description": "Rare, source-faithful canonical term with strong semantic stability and low immediate legibility.",
          "candidateKind": "canonical_term",
          "semanticCluster": "rare-disciplinary",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "A public display label may differ from the canonical term.",
            "The term receives a glossary and retrieval aliases."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "High stability and source fidelity.",
            "Requires orientation for many readers."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Reader abandonment when no accessible display layer is present.",
            "AI over-association with historical psychology without local context."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Cross-model interpretation checks and small reader-legibility review.",
          "estimate": 0.42,
          "lowerBound": 0.34,
          "upperBound": 0.52,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 8.9,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 8.2,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 8.7,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 8.8,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 9.5,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 9.2,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.0
          },
          "decisionState": "selected",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/conative-behavior",
          "displayName": "Conative behavior",
          "description": "A more contemporary disciplinary term balancing technical specificity and initial readability.",
          "candidateKind": "canonical_term",
          "semanticCluster": "disciplinary-balanced",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "Behavior language remains acceptable for the intended collaboration register."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "Good stability.",
            "May sound observational rather than motion-oriented."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Conceptual flattening from motion into behavior category."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Terminological collision review and source-fidelity comparison.",
          "estimate": 0.16,
          "lowerBound": 0.08,
          "upperBound": 0.26,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 8.5,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 7.4,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 7.8,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 8.4,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 8.8,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 8.5,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 6.8
          },
          "decisionState": "held",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/volitional-actions",
          "displayName": "Volitional actions",
          "description": "Highly legible technical phrase with moderate drift exposure in popular and AI discourse.",
          "candidateKind": "public_or_technical_term",
          "semanticCluster": "legible-academic",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "Volition carries the intended motivational and directional sense."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "High immediate legibility.",
            "Lower long-term semantic stability."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Normative or agency-heavy interpretation.",
            "Semantic softening through popular use."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Cross-model drift review and register assessment.",
          "estimate": 0.13,
          "lowerBound": 0.05,
          "upperBound": 0.23,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 7.6,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 8.9,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 9.0,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 7.5,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 7.2,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 7.8,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.6
          },
          "decisionState": "held",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/motor-intentions",
          "displayName": "Motor intentions",
          "description": "Neuroscience-adjacent technical term with high legibility in movement contexts and narrower conceptual scope.",
          "candidateKind": "domain_adapter",
          "semanticCluster": "neuroscience",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "The concept is close enough to embodied movement to justify motor-language emphasis."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "Strong technical anchor.",
            "May exclude non-motor conative state."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Over-narrowing toward physical movement."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Scope comparison against non-motor examples.",
          "estimate": 0.1,
          "lowerBound": 0.02,
          "upperBound": 0.2,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 8.0,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 8.8,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 8.2,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 7.9,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 5.5,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 6.5,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.2
          },
          "decisionState": "declined",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        },
        {
          "id": "vs:candidate/motivated-movements",
          "displayName": "Motivated movements",
          "description": "Plainly readable phrase with broad movement semantics and moderate commercial or wellness drift.",
          "candidateKind": "display_term",
          "semanticCluster": "plain-language",
          "origin": "source_exemplar",
          "assumptions": [
            "A broad display label is valuable even when the canonical type remains more technical."
          ],
          "tradeoffs": [
            "Strong readability.",
            "Meaning may broaden beyond the intended construct."
          ],
          "failureModes": [
            "Fitness or self-help interpretation.",
            "Loss of volitional nuance."
          ],
          "evidenceNeeded": "Reader comprehension review and public-register collision search.",
          "estimate": 0.07,
          "lowerBound": 0,
          "upperBound": 0.17,
          "estimateKind": "planning_judgment",
          "measurementStatus": "planning_estimate",
          "calibrationState": "uncalibrated",
          "estimatorRef": "vs:estimator/ai-supported-planning-pass",
          "basis": "Uncalibrated planning estimate derived from the attached naming exploration; it is not an empirical frequency.",
          "confidence": "moderate",
          "dimensionScores": {
            "vs:dimension/semantic-stability": 7.2,
            "vs:dimension/human-legibility": 9.0,
            "vs:dimension/ai-legibility": 8.6,
            "vs:dimension/cross-model-portability": 7.0,
            "vs:dimension/source-fidelity": 6.2,
            "vs:dimension/future-refactorability": 6.8,
            "vs:dimension/accessibility": 8.4
          },
          "decisionState": "declined",
          "componentCandidateRefs": [],
          "exclusiveWithRefs": [],
          "compatibleWithRefs": [],
          "sourceRefs": [
            "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
          ],
          "reviewState": "working"
        }
      ],
      "startedAt": "2026-06-20T16:20:00Z",
      "completedAt": "2026-06-20T16:30:00Z",
      "valueOrigin": "human_led_ai_supported",
      "reviewState": "working"
    }
  ],
  "activeRunId": "vs:run/layered-label",
  "comparison": {
    "id": "vs:comparison/layered-vs-baseline",
    "baselineRunId": "vs:run/baseline-single-label",
    "comparisonRunId": "vs:run/layered-label",
    "commensurabilityState": "commensurate_with_declared_condition_change",
    "comparisonBasis": "Stable candidate IDs; same outcome, population, horizon, and base dimensions.",
    "reviewState": "working"
  },
  "gaps": [
    {
      "id": "vs:gap/calibration-absent",
      "runRef": "vs:run/layered-label",
      "gapType": "calibration_absent",
      "description": "The probabilities are planning estimates and have no empirical calibration against future naming outcomes.",
      "consequence": "Values support structured deliberation and variant comparison; they do not establish forecast accuracy.",
      "gapUtility": "coordination_gap",
      "currentHandling": "route_to_Research_Atlas",
      "evidenceNeeded": "Longitudinal cross-model and reader-observation records.",
      "routeTargetId": "ra:research-atlas",
      "resolutionState": "open",
      "valueOrigin": "human_led_ai_supported",
      "confidence": "confirmed",
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:gap/human-vocabulary",
      "runRef": "vs:run/layered-label",
      "gapType": "human_vocabulary_gap",
      "description": "Different readers may lack the disciplinary vocabulary needed to interpret rare canonical terms.",
      "consequence": "A reader-facing label and orientation layer may be required even when the canonical term remains stable.",
      "gapUtility": "coordination_gap",
      "currentHandling": "route_to_Context_Tree",
      "evidenceNeeded": "Reader cohorts, knowledge needs, and missing-context observations.",
      "routeTargetId": "ca:context-tree",
      "resolutionState": "open",
      "valueOrigin": "human_led_ai_supported",
      "confidence": "high",
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:gap/collision-review",
      "runRef": "vs:run/layered-label",
      "gapType": "legal_or_collision_review",
      "description": "Public and technical collision review remains incomplete for several candidates and aliases.",
      "consequence": "Promotion into a public registry remains review-bound.",
      "gapUtility": "coordination_gap",
      "currentHandling": "route_to_Terminological_Registry",
      "evidenceNeeded": "Terminology registry search, package search, and public-surface collision review.",
      "routeTargetId": "is:terminological-registry",
      "resolutionState": "open",
      "valueOrigin": "human_declared",
      "confidence": "high",
      "reviewState": "working"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:gap/model-portability",
      "runRef": "vs:run/layered-label",
      "gapType": "model_or_version_unknown",
      "description": "The candidates have not been tested across a sufficiently broad set of model families and versions.",
      "consequence": "Cross-model portability scores remain hypotheses.",
      "gapUtility": "coordination_gap",
      "currentHandling": "route_to_Practitioner_Probe",
      "evidenceNeeded": "Controlled prompt probes across models with stable contexts.",
      "routeTargetId": "ca:practitioner-judgment-probes",
      "resolutionState": "open",
      "valueOrigin": "ai_inferred",
      "confidence": "moderate",
      "reviewState": "working"
    }
  ],
  "statisticalFit": {
    "enabled": false,
    "statisticName": "",
    "statisticValue": null,
    "modelClass": "",
    "observedDataRef": "",
    "sampleSize": null,
    "population": "",
    "referenceModel": "",
    "assumptions": [],
    "diagnostics": [],
    "sourceOfTruthBand": [],
    "asOf": "2026-06-21",
    "reviewState": "not_applicable_without_observed_data"
  },
  "shiftHypotheses": [
    {
      "id": "vs:shift/layered-labels-raise-conation",
      "outcomeDefinitionRef": "vs:outcome/name-hold-conation-motion",
      "candidateRef": "vs:candidate/conation-motions",
      "proposedChange": "Use Conation motions as the stable canonical term while providing an accessible display label and retrieval aliases.",
      "expectedDirection": "raise",
      "expectedMagnitude": "+0.14 planning-estimate points",
      "mechanism": "The layered naming contract preserves the low-drift source term while moving first-encounter legibility into a separate reader-facing layer.",
      "assumptions": [
        "The display label remains linked to the canonical ID.",
        "Documentation consistently presents the alias relation."
      ],
      "confounders": [
        "Model-specific familiarity with conation",
        "Reader tolerance for technical terminology"
      ],
      "evidenceRefs": [
        "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
      ],
      "falsifier": "Cross-model and reader tests show that the layered labels increase confusion or fragment retrieval.",
      "evaluationPlanRef": "ra:research-demand/layered-naming-portability",
      "causalStatus": "mechanism_hypothesis",
      "reviewState": "working"
    }
  ],
  "decision": {
    "id": "vs:decision/conation-motion-name",
    "selectedCandidateIds": [
      "vs:candidate/conation-motions"
    ],
    "heldCandidateIds": [
      "vs:candidate/conative-behavior",
      "vs:candidate/volitional-actions"
    ],
    "declinedCandidateIds": [
      "vs:candidate/motor-intentions",
      "vs:candidate/motivated-movements"
    ],
    "decisionRule": "Prefer the candidate with the strongest combined semantic stability, source fidelity, and future refactorability when a separate accessible display layer is available.",
    "probabilityRole": "informative",
    "rationale": "The layered naming arrangement raises the practical viability of the most stable source-faithful term while preserving accessible public language.",
    "dissentOrMinorityRead": "Conative behavior remains a credible balanced canonical alternative if layered labels prove too costly.",
    "unresolvedGapIds": [
      "vs:gap/calibration-absent",
      "vs:gap/human-vocabulary",
      "vs:gap/collision-review",
      "vs:gap/model-portability"
    ],
    "updateTriggers": [
      "Material terminology collision",
      "Cross-model retrieval failure",
      "Reader comprehension evidence",
      "Schema or package boundary change"
    ],
    "decisionAuthorityRef": "na:stewardship-authority/conation-motion",
    "humanReviewState": "working_decision",
    "effectiveAt": "2026-06-21",
    "reviewAfter": "2026-09-21",
    "reviewState": "working"
  },
  "routeSelections": [
    {
      "id": "vs:route/strategy-canvas",
      "routeTargetId": "ca:strategy-canvas",
      "routeType": "core_architecture",
      "routeReason": "Compare how the naming candidates perform across the declared dimensions and layered naming conditions.",
      "payloadRefs": [
        "vs:run/baseline-single-label",
        "vs:run/layered-label",
        "vs:dimension/semantic-stability",
        "vs:dimension/human-legibility"
      ],
      "expectedReturn": "Dimension-level current/future comparison and good-enough threshold.",
      "receiptRequired": true,
      "routeState": "prepared"
    },
    {
      "id": "vs:route/terminological-registry",
      "routeTargetId": "is:terminological-registry",
      "routeType": "stewardship",
      "routeReason": "Resolve canonical, display, authored, technical, alias, and collision states.",
      "payloadRefs": [
        "vs:candidate/conation-motions",
        "vs:candidate/conative-behavior",
        "vs:gap/collision-review"
      ],
      "expectedReturn": "Reviewed terminology entry and promotion decision.",
      "receiptRequired": true,
      "routeState": "prepared"
    }
  ],
  "boundary": {
    "visibility": "public_safe",
    "privateLocatorsIncluded": false,
    "unreviewedInferenceIncludedInPublic": false,
    "sourceLocalAnnotationIncludedInPublic": false,
    "publicSafeSourceMarker": "Public-safe adaptation of the source-owned naming-planning exemplar; reviewed semantic references are retained and private locators are absent.",
    "disclosedOmissions": [
      "Private source locators",
      "Unreviewed workspace-specific annotation"
    ],
    "reviewState": "public_reviewed"
  },
  "viewState": {
    "selectedCandidateId": "vs:candidate/conation-motions",
    "blendCandidateIds": [],
    "candidateSort": "probability",
    "candidateSearch": "",
    "routeFamilyFilter": "all",
    "routeSearch": "",
    "activeInspectorTab": "candidate",
    "showIntervals": true,
    "showTail": true
  },
  "sourceNote": {
    "researchAnchor": {
      "id": "arxiv:2510.01171",
      "title": "Verbalized Sampling: How to Mitigate Mode Collapse and Unlock LLM Diversity",
      "role": "Canonical technique grounding for eliciting multiple responses and a verbalized distribution."
    },
    "adaptationBoundary": "The research technique is used as a diversity intervention. This prototype adds source-linked decision state, dimensional fit, methodological gaps, route records, and parallel human/system views.",
    "planningExemplars": [
      "na:indeterminate-slot-map-planning-proposal/v0.1",
      "na:terminological-registry-planning-proposal/v0.1",
      "na:conation-motion-naming-exemplar/v0.1"
    ],
    "coreArchitectureHydration": "ca-artifact-core-architecture-family-index-001"
  }
}